Dunkel

First Man: Ignore the 'ridiculous' controversy, this is Oscar gold

CBC News
Abonnieren
Aufrufe 30 214
75% 305 101

First Man has been dogged with controversy, with some saying it's unpatriotic. But rest assured, the movie shows America at its best. And the return pairing of Ryan Gosling and Damien Chazelle have produced an real Oscar contender.
»»» Subscribe to CBC News to watch more videos: bit.ly/1RreYWS
Connect with CBC News Online:
For breaking news, video, audio and in-depth coverage: bit.ly/1Z0m6iX
Find CBC News on Facebook: bit.ly/1WjG36m
Follow CBC News on Twitter: bit.ly/1sA5P9H
For breaking news on Twitter: bit.ly/1WjDyks
Follow CBC News on Instagram: bit.ly/1Z0iE7O
Download the CBC News app for iOS: apple.co/25mpsUz
Download the CBC News app for Android: bit.ly/1XxuozZ
»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»
For more than 75 years, CBC News has been the source Canadians turn to, to keep them informed about their communities, their country and their world. Through regional and national programming on multiple platforms, including CBC Television, CBC News Network, CBC Radio, CBCNews.ca, mobile and on-demand, CBC News and its internationally recognized team of award-winning journalists deliver the breaking stories, the issues, the analyses and the personalities that matter to Canadians.

Am

 

12 Okt 2018

first manryan goslingclaire foydamien chazelledamien chazzellereviewunpatrioticcriticcontroversyflagpatrioticpatriotismeli glasnermovie reviewcbc newscbc

Teilen:

Link:

Video herunterladen:

Link wird geladen...

Hinzufügen:

Meine Playlist
Später ansehen
KOMMENTARE 354
chrislox1
chrislox1 Vor 2 Tage
But then they often pick the wrong movies for Oscars!
Danny Hudack
Danny Hudack Vor 6 Tage
Next up: a movie about Iwo Jima, but it won't show the flag raising. Oh wait....it will be visible on Mt Suribachi way off in the distance, already up. Then a movie about Titanic, but they wont show the ice berg.
Adrien Roy
Adrien Roy Vor 9 Tage
Love the subject, I'm a space junkie. Movie was a big...big disappointment.
Nnelg Drahcir
Nnelg Drahcir Vor Monat
I don't get it! where's the German flag?
J Henry Phillips
J Henry Phillips Vor 2 Monate
Republicans will complain until CGI bumper stickers on the ship say: Love it or Leave it! Four More Years (of Nixon), and Member: Silent Majority.
F.u.c.k Allah
F.u.c.k Allah Vor 2 Monate
Apparently the US flag is powerful enough to trigger so many people
Kareem Salessi
Kareem Salessi Vor 2 Monate
PARTICIPATE IN THIS APOLLO-RESEARCH-CHALLENGE, if you want to find out for yourself what Apollos really were: Open each search in a new tab: GOOGLE: (“Saturn V Rocket Launch Speed and Height“) GOOGLE: ("Flyers are REQUIRED to insure a safe flight profile for their rockets.") GOOGLE: ("GoFast Part of CSXT Family") Now: If viewers first go through GOOGLE: (“Solving-Spacex-Enigma”) and its links, with patience, they can become rocket-literate, especially by understanding that even the lightest toy-rockets need a TWR>6 to vertically lift off their launch pads, for at least 100 meters. TWR==(Thrust-Weight-Ratio), which for Apollos was only 1.25, like TWR of a simple Helium-Balloon! Apollos ascended as slow as Helium-Balloons with a constant speed of 9 meters/second, and WITHOUT ACCELERATION! On the contrary, rockets need to launch with at least 5-G acceleration, or they stall and fall! TWR>6 (==6 G) is a rocket’s minimum necessary thrust-weight-ratio, because 1G-thrust-force-equivalent (from the total 6G) barely neutralizes the 1-G-(Gravity-Pull), keeping the rocket buoyant in air, like a floating balloon, while the other 5-G is the minimum necessary force to push the rocket straight up, with acceleration, without which a rocket stalls, tips over, and falls! In contrast to the above-cited Apollo-Launch-Data, all Apollo-launch-films show that they ascend at a constant balloon speed of around 9 meters/second, but without acceleration, while clearing tower, which is why all their horizontal-view launch-films are cut immediately upon Apollos clearing tower, so that viewers can NOT see how many launch-tower-lengths they cover as they ascend, in how many seconds. For further deceptions, camera is quickly switched to Apollos’ view from underneath, because Apollos’ close distance to the ground could NOT be visible from below them! The record-breaking GoFast-rocket, had a TWR==125, and ascended 73 miles, which you can see by copy-pasting in DE-vid: (GoFast rocket thrust). TWR=125 is 100 times that of an Apollo-TWR==1.25 Now, by performing the equivalency calculations below, you can see that for an Apollo (3,000 tons) to have reached the initial 73 miles, of its claimed launch altitude, it would have required a thrust-force equivalent to 1,000,000 times (ONE MILLION TIMES) of its weight (contrary to Apollo’s claimed-thrust of 1.25 times of its weight); Thus an Apollo would have required 3,000,000,000 (3-billion-tons) of Thrust-Force to make just the initial 73 miles of its claimed mythical flight! GoFast-Rocket, 2018 record-holder, with 73-miles-high-record-vertical-launch: delivering 44,000 kgf (force) on a 350 kg (weight), high-tech-rocket, which was much more efficient in deploying every gram of thrust-force, than all rockets of 10-50 years ago: 44,000 kgf/350 kg==125==TWR, as opposed to Apollo-TWR==1.25==BALLOON-TWR. NOW: SHOCKER-APOLLO-TWR-EQUIVALENCY-MATH: The actual TWR a GoFast-comparable-Apollo would have needed, to vertically ascend the first 73 miles of its claimed flight-path-to-the-Moon, is the equivalent of: ((3,000,000 (kg-Apollo-Weight) X 125)) / 350 kg ==1,071,428≈≈1,000,000≈≈Apollo-TWR-DEMAND! CONCLUSION: Apollos were unmanned-vertical-airships (BALLOONS), going NOWHERE! Second proof: DE-vid: (Amateur rocket reaches 121,000 ft) Applying similar method, to this Qu8K-Real-Rocket, I calculate the Apollo-TWR-Demand-Equivalency: Qu8K-rocket-weight=320 lbs; its Thrust=4,000 lbs; (TWR==4,000/320=12.5); Apogee: 121,000ft==23 miles altitude; Apollo-Claimed-Weight==6,500,000 lbs; Now, shocker-equivalency-math: ((6,500,000 (lbs-Apollo-Weight) X 12.5)) / 320 lbs== 254,000==Apollo-TWR-Demand to reach the first 23 miles of its mythical flight-path! Meaning: Apollo needed at least a thrust-force equivalent to 254,000 times of its weight, in order to fly up its first 23 miles! With its claimed-thrust-force of 1.25 times of its weight, Apollo could NOT lift off the ground, NOT one inch! CONCLUSION: Apollos were Unmanned-Vertical-Airships (BALLOONS), slightly pushed up with fireworks propulsion! Mark Twain: "It is easier to fool people, than to convince them that they have been fooled." Carl Sagan: "We have been bamboozled for so long, that we no longer care about it..!" Thanks. K.S.
Lappan Sommer
Lappan Sommer Vor 2 Monate
+Kareem Salessi You somehow failed to notice that that 50 seconds is across two separate camera shots (clearly labelled as "Camera 1" and "Camera 2") - the actual ascent from launch until crossing the power wires is 26 seconds. I replied in that thread pointing out some further errors, but I must confess to some glee at being upbraided for not paying attention by someone who has failed to notice that it launched twice.
Kareem Salessi
Kareem Salessi Vor 2 Monate
+Lappan Sommer 50 seconds as filmed by Nikon-P1000 in my related comment under its video where you wrote your other nonsense, which you obviously did NOT pay attention to, but just dumped your gibberish!
Lappan Sommer
Lappan Sommer Vor 2 Monate
+Kareem Salessi If you understand that that the acceleration increases with mass loss then why do you assume that the initial acceleration determines total performance? The 2014 GoFast launch reported 23g at launch, burn time 13s to altitude 15km and top speed 5500km/h, after which it coasted ballistically to 116km altitude. Classic sounding rocket: punch through atmosphere hard and fast, soar high, drop. Not at all like an orbital profile, let alone a manned one. Also your figures look wrong: reported time by SpaceX to 800m altitude for Falcon-9 is 20 seconds (as seen on any launch video), time to 60m (measured against service mast) 8 seconds. What's your source for 50 seconds?
Kareem Salessi
Kareem Salessi Vor 2 Monate
+Lappan Sommer I replied to you under another channel. You don't have a clue what acceleration is! Above is comparing like with like. The above professional rockets also start losing weight after launch. Take any other actual-rocket's performance & put its numbers in the above equivalency-equation to understand that Apollos, SpaceX, etc. are NOT rockets. For instance put the numbers for this one which only goes up half-mile in DE-vid: (World Record Model Rocket Launch - 3/4 Scale Mercury Redstone) Click on SORT-COMMENTS BY NEWEST to see the rocket's numbers in comments, then put them in above equation (for an Apollo) to see that Apollo would have needed the equivalent force of hundreds of times of its own weight, just to go up half-a-mile, which the above model rocket did in just 4 seconds, while Apollo claimed ascending 25 meters in 4 second, and the latest SpaceX took 50 seconds to climb an equal half-mile, thus neither Apollos, nor SpaceX could be rockets!
Kareem Salessi
Kareem Salessi Vor 2 Monate
+RogHawk I was corrected? What do you mean exactly? "Carl Sagan": "We have been bamboozled for so long... www.goodreads.com/quotes/85171-one-of-the-saddest-lessons-of-history-is-this-if
marcducati
marcducati Vor 3 Monate
Brilliant movie. Americans love over the top patriotisme but it gets old very quickly. This movie has classe and will become a classic.
Anthony Barraza
Anthony Barraza Vor 3 Monate
This is garbage . Earth is flat
vancouveride
vancouveride Vor 3 Monate
The astronauts seemed to go through the entire picture in the grip of some sort of despondency. Constantly staring off camera trying to reign in their depression, Walking to their spacecraft as if to their own funeral. Apparently even walking to a Saturn 5 doesn't cause the slightest nervous smile. Not even landing on the moon with seconds of fuel left is cause for a smile. The technology is portrayed as ill suited to the task by having all of the cockpit doors sound like something from Das Boot, close ups of large rivets etc. This is a movie about how the Apollo missions were not about a bunch of highly competent and daring men doing great things but instead a bunch of crazy people trapped in a nightmare of their own making who inexplicably lucked out despite their inability to express their emotions. There is a difference between seriousness and depression but this seems lost by the makers of this movie.
Entrenched Mgtow
Entrenched Mgtow Vor 3 Monate
Hollywood quietly re-inserted the American flag into the moon landing AFTER the huge (now quietly shuffled aside) controversy. The moon landing by the AMERICANS is an AMERICAN achievement. The AMERICAN flag planting on the moon represents the accomplishment by AMERICANS, and the AMERICAN taxpayers and the brilliant minds at NASA.
boricualink
boricualink Vor 6 Tage
The movie makes it pretty clear that it was americs that landed on the moon.
Elijah cesspoole
Elijah cesspoole Vor 3 Monate
The best movie I´ve seen in over a decade.
Roy Morales
Roy Morales Vor 3 Monate
No controversy. Patrotic and thrilling space scenes. I am Retired Lt Col that worked on the Space Shuttle program. This also displayed Neil's love for his daughter throughout the movie.
SoloWatcher86
SoloWatcher86 Vor 3 Monate
As an American, the thing that gripes me most about these reactionary Conservatives (wait, actually a lot gripes me) is that they will fail to see a movie they would actually appreciate most, a movie about a real American hero, just because they read some dumb tweet.
Danny Hudack
Danny Hudack Vor 6 Tage
Wrong. As an American, which obviously you are not, THE crowning achievement of the space race was the flag planting on the moon. I saw adults SOB when it happened live. Neil knew it. His mission was to do it. He did it spectacularly. The director left it out ON PURPOSE (his words, not mine). It wasnt a tweet that stopped the majority of real Americans from watching it. You think that then you wont learn from your mistakes.
boricualink
boricualink Vor 6 Tage
+Danny Hudack its a 2 hour movie they couldnt show everything. They show the flag just not its planting. Its a movie about neil armstrong, his sons worked on the movie. Its not about america. I doubt his sons would give their blessings to a antiamerican movie. Its about a man, its about being a man and what you need to do to accomplish your mission. Something youre obviously not familiar with.
Danny Hudack
Danny Hudack Vor Monat
No, not due to a tweet at all. Rather, due to being tricked by the hollywood leftists one too many times to trust them, thus we look at every movie with a bit of suspicion. When the director, yes THE DIRECTOR said he left it out on purpose that said it all to me. Not a tweet.
njt002
njt002 Vor 3 Monate
I saw the film and I'm an American. American patriotism never even entered my mind. This film was about a man who was part of a historic victory for the entire world. The planting of the American flag wasn't important and was not a necessary part of the film.
Danny Hudack
Danny Hudack Vor Monat
I bet you didnt witness the landing live did you?
Nate Carlson
Nate Carlson Vor 3 Monate
This was an amazing movie, probably my favourite astronaut flick. Ryan Gosling and Claire Foy were amazing, I can't wait to see what they do next (especially local boy Ryan Gosling, following up Blade Runner 2049 with another fantastic performance). Great review as always, Eli!
Cicero Araujo
Cicero Araujo Vor 3 Monate
I give it all the stars
Martin Rheaume
Martin Rheaume Vor 3 Monate
Best damn movie of the year!
Neil Armstrong
Neil Armstrong Vor 3 Monate
Yeah !
Tony Fox
Tony Fox Vor 3 Monate
This movie is about a lie.
Curious Cat
Curious Cat Vor 3 Monate
If this film wins any oscars, it´s for best supporting actress, Claire Foy is amazing in the film. But apart from that, I don´t think it´s a big oscar monster. But I bet it will win a couple more oscars because it revolves around an american hero.
Mehdi Yasaee
Mehdi Yasaee Vor 3 Monate
The whole moon landing sequence is one of the most poetic and epic scenes in film. That alone justifies watching this movie on the big screen. Brilliant.
PETER PEARSON
PETER PEARSON Vor Monat
You know it didn't happen right?
Vitto Corleone
Vitto Corleone Vor 3 Monate
Its a must watch movie
timber_beast
timber_beast Vor 3 Monate
The problem with this movie is it seems like Terrence Malick directed it.
J
J Vor 3 Monate
Where do you get these little guys
Afonso Lucas
Afonso Lucas Vor 3 Monate
How are there so many dense people.
GlassTopRX7
GlassTopRX7 Vor 4 Monate
No this was a poorly written and edit film with below average acting. For visuals maybe but that's it. In terms of Historical space films it's a distant 4th behind Apollo 13, The Right Stuff and The Challenger Disaster. Yes the The Challenger Disaster despite it's low budget was a better movie.
Space Faring Civilisation
I loved first man. The editing style reminds me a bit of 2001, and great story. It’ll be a classic.
Nebulous
Nebulous Vor 4 Monate
We did ignore it. Why do you think the movie failed?
Abbas Zaidi
Abbas Zaidi Vor 4 Monate
Another point with understated acting. When the Armstrong’s arrive in Houston and Pat White asks Janet (pregnant with Mark) “is that your first?” There’s a moment, pang of regret when I thought she would say it’s my third, opening the door to Karen’s story. She swerved this and says “we already have a son”. It’s those little moments. And while I loved watching it on imax I’m looking forward to seeing those little moments again on the small screen
Marvelous Marv
Marvelous Marv Vor 4 Monate
Oscar gold? I walked out of it. Terrible movie. Armstrong was not frowning all the time because he was depressed--he was stoic because he had exceptional skill at what he did and nothing to prove. I love the exposition in the movie: "Neil plays the piano." Why not just show him playing the piano instead of telling us he plays? From La La Land, it is obvious that Ryan Gosling can play. Watch any interview of Neil Armstrong (or any of the astronauts from the 60's) and you will see confidence, skill and love of country. You will not see a sad, depressed man who only joined the space program because his daughter died. I know this movie was not meant to be a documentary but this is a pure example where life is way more interesting than art. Watch "In the Shadow of the Moon" and read the exceptional "Carrying the Fire" by Michael Collins (the command pilot from Apollo 11.) By the way, the real Ed White was a superb athlete who almost made it to the Olympics, not a pudgy confidant as depicted in this film. That being said--I loved the scene in the Gemini 8.
Philip Croft
Philip Croft Vor 4 Monate
who made this comic show--Disney?
twincams350
twincams350 Vor 4 Monate
The planting of the flag of the United States on the moon was one of the most notable moments of the entire space program. That simple act told the world that America had beat the Soviet Union in the space race. No, the world did not beat the Soviets. AMERICA did. Mankind did not beat the Soviets. AMERICA did. And the world cheered. To exclude that aspect of the mission in the movie, and to usurp the title of Neil Armstrong's biography for this movie on top of that, is an absolute disgrace. Since they've used that title, there can't be another movie with that title that gives proper homage to the spirit of America that put those men on the moon. What they've done is tantamount to somebody taking a priceless Rembrandt original painting and using it as a placemat at Taco Bell.
twincams350
twincams350 Vor 3 Monate
+Alexander Punturi, the liberal definition of a "smart" person is somebody who blindly follows left-wing ideology, no questions asked. I therefore agree with you 100%
Alexander Punturi
Alexander Punturi Vor 3 Monate
you have to be smart to like this movie. It doesn’t look like you like this movie...
Whoopsie DayZ
Whoopsie DayZ Vor 3 Monate
It would have been kind of weird to show the planting of the flag itself. I thought it was nonsense not to have it in the movie when I first heard it. Watching it, it made sense. The movie is more about Neil himself and his grief. When he is on the moon he finally finds peace with his grief and problems and they decide to only show that very short. This movie is more about Neil and his life than the mission itself.
Mozart1220
Mozart1220 Vor 4 Monate
I wonder if the people whining about not showing them planting the flag would also want to see that flag blown down by the liftoff when they left. LOL Plus, given decades of solar radiation they all look like we surrendered up there anyway. www.skyandtelescope.com/astronomy-news/what-happened-to-the-flags-on-the-moon/
Chris Groves
Chris Groves Vor 4 Monate
He volunteered for the program....not thrust into the program....
Vermiliontea
Vermiliontea Vor 4 Monate
You just don't get it. It's not that the flag planting moment was missing in the movie. It's that they made the *DECISION* not to have it in the movie. I won't see this movie, no matter how good it is. And neither will anybody I know. - F* hollywood to H*!
195511SM
195511SM Vor 4 Monate
lt sounds like something l would probably rent........but the rental places all went out of business several years ago. NOT gong to drop $$$ to see a movie in a theater that's likely to put me to sleep. l learned MY lesson with 'The English Patient'.
Richard Mourdock
Richard Mourdock Vor 4 Monate
Appreciate the CBC review. far better than we'd get here in the states. A brilliant movie, though not a space movie as many anticipate... a critical autobiography of sorts.
Richard Mourdock
Richard Mourdock Vor 3 Monate
With all respect, it is not a "space movie" like Apollo XIII or the Martian. It is about a person who excelled in space, of course, but the main theme is about how the person Neil Armstrong dealt with the personal challenges and dangers that defined his life.
Alexander Punturi
Alexander Punturi Vor 3 Monate
Richard Mourdock it is certainly a space movie... how is it not?
Bob Riemersma
Bob Riemersma Vor 4 Monate
Who is that fop in the incredibly awful jacket stolen off a Chinese game show host? Oh, never mind: CBC!
Nx Doyle
Nx Doyle Vor 4 Monate
You know what's worse than the news media blowing a non-story up into a so-called controversy? Pretending to take the high road while doing exactly the same thing.
Alan Q. Wake
Alan Q. Wake Vor 4 Monate
Omg they still showed the flag there's no controversy.
Nebulous
Nebulous Vor 6 Tage
+boricualink - It's very simple let me explain it to you like this. You lost the White House, The Senate and The Supreme Court but you got the House of Reps. So (like this movie) you're not a total loser BUT you've definitely failed to hit your goals.
boricualink
boricualink Vor 6 Tage
+Nebulous only in conservative circles is making more money then you spent considered a flop. Must be that trump math your using.
Nebulous
Nebulous Vor 6 Tage
+boricualink - Yea when you don't stick the landing it means you failed to hit your goal. That one's for free sugar plum. buh bye
boricualink
boricualink Vor 6 Tage
+Nebulous whoopsie guess you didnt read the article sweetie. "First Man didn’t stick the landing, that’s for sure, but the ship hasn’t crashed completely"
boricualink
boricualink Vor 6 Tage
+Nebulous no it actually says the opposite
Gray Logix
Gray Logix Vor 4 Monate
Decades back our technology was limited and still managed to land on moon.... But why not now... ? We have smart phones and microcontroller chips so powerful and tiny and cost effective as well... There should be at least a flight to the moon daily once or twice in the current technology.
Chris Weidner
Chris Weidner Vor 4 Monate
"Ridiculous controversy"?? I think not. Choosing to not place the American flag on an American astronaut speaks to a dark agenda. Please people: cherish and learn from one another. Help save our Republic.
MrSpuzzz
MrSpuzzz Vor 4 Monate
Why Gosling? Armstrong was the epitome of confident but humble and gracious. Gosling has the confidence part down, but that’s as far as it goes.
Master Warning
Master Warning Vor 4 Monate
Movie sucked...HBO series From the Earth to the Moon is 10 times better. The Gemini, Apollo and Lunar Module depicted as rattle traps that have grit and grime, grease and basically filthy interiors with worn out switches..made the spacecraft seem like basket cases. Neil and Buzz portrayed so poorly. Don’t waste your money.
Marvelous Marv
Marvelous Marv Vor 4 Monate
I agree 1 million percent.
kraigthorne
kraigthorne Vor 4 Monate
3:15 I have seen several hours of interviews with Niel Armstrong and he DOES NOT act like that!!! He smiles more than the other two astronauts and he jokes more than they do. When it comes to historic accuracy First Man is as accurate as Braveheart.
boricualink
boricualink Vor 6 Tage
Watcc "first man to the moon" his sons and his first wife talk about how he was very quiet and reserved. His mother found out he became an astronaut thru the TV, he didnt even tell his mom. He was forced into giving interviews as part of the mission. those interviews dont depict his real personality. Heres a link de-vid.com/video/video-CD-OcW3Qhjg.html his sister talks about how their mom found out he was an astronaut at around the 22 or 23 minute mark. And his sons talk about how he was very quiet and serious and didnt "loosen up" until much later in life. After his second marriage in tye 90's
pagamenews
pagamenews Vor 4 Monate
Oscar gold? I seriously doubt that this movie will even get nominated. Even the most hardcore NASA/Apollo fans have said publicly on DE-vid that the movie did not meet their expectations. One person said that it seemed like, "Ryan Gosling playing Neil Armstrong playing Ryan Gosling."
pagamenews
pagamenews Vor 4 Monate
No need to go out and see the movie now. This man just described the entire film from beginning to end. THANKS!
Marvelous Marv
Marvelous Marv Vor 4 Monate
Did he give away the ending to you? LOL--I'll spoil it. On the way to the moon, an oxygen tank explodes and...
Jennifur68
Jennifur68 Vor 4 Monate
Canadian Broadcasting Corporation praises Canadian film as "Oscar gold." No bias there.
kraigthorne
kraigthorne Vor 4 Monate
I have seen the movie and several interviews with Niel Armstrong and watched several documentaries about him and he was much more compassionate than the movie makes him out to be. It is an OK movie, there were some parts that were fantastic and other parts that were pure fiction (mainly dealing with Buzz Aldren)
Steve G.A.
Steve G.A. Vor 4 Monate
Controversy? What controversy? Everyone who has a bit of an education should know what these brave men did and the nation that ran the program. This movie is about the life and struggles of an amazing human being, not about outdated and overrated patriotism. For that, go watch bad war movies by Mel Gibson.
Addy Kumaro
Addy Kumaro Vor 24 Tage
This film was so boring. I wanted to see armstrong the person not the husband. Also the effects where garbage didnt even show the rocket with flames take off he could of been in a bedrokm for all we know. This film. Was a flop i never got so bored in a movie.
PETER PEARSON
PETER PEARSON Vor Monat
+barry nicholas see this is the contraversey. They never went to the moon. If you say the truth your a traitor. You want to be seen as unpatriotic or a traitor? Tell the truth about the moon landing. People rather you be patriotic than truthful.
barry nicholas
barry nicholas Vor 3 Monate
+Wario About the Apollo Missions yes I do know more than them.
Wario
Wario Vor 3 Monate
barry nicholas oh they didn’t? I guess you know more than every credible historian lol
barry nicholas
barry nicholas Vor 3 Monate
They never went to the moon, but Armstrong was instructed to say they did because NASA and the government said so.
nocalsteve
nocalsteve Vor 4 Monate
This guy always talks too much about the plot points of the movie. I'm sorry I watched this.
terry waller
terry waller Vor 4 Monate
It's garbage, erases one of the most important historical moments! I will never watch it on any fornat!
Rick Jones
Rick Jones Vor 4 Monate
Hollywood decided that showing planting the flag wasn't important but making up a fictional scene of Neil dropping his daughter's bracelet into Little West crater was? Opie (Ron Howard) did the same thing in Apollo 13 with his made up argument between Fred Haise and Jack Swigert. Opie said he did it for dramatic effect. Really? The fact that the whole side of the Service Module had just been blown out, your venting your oxygen into space, and you don't have enough power for the duration of the mission is not enough drama? Really? Beating the Russians to the moon and demonstrating that capitalism is a better form of government than communism WAS the mission. But the socialist run education system of the US no longer teaches actual history any more otherwise you would know this.
dskyyksd
dskyyksd Vor 4 Monate
Offended because there's no flag scene in a movie about Neil Armstrong? Please. Apollo 11 was the achievement of a generation of Americans who have mostly passed on. The only thing "we" have done is defund NASA until we're hitching rides from the Russians to the ISS.
Danny Hudack
Danny Hudack Vor Monat
Remember it was hussein obama who cancelled the Constellation program.
daniel letterman
daniel letterman Vor 4 Monate
The perspective of this movie is from the point of view of "the first man" Neil Armstrong based on a book written by an author who really got to know the man. It underscored the danger, the resolve, the hyper analytic mind needed and the burden of emotion that came with being an astronaut, father and husband. It also highlighted the words of Neil Armstrong "That's one small step for a man, one giant leap for mankind". The movie did the above, very well. If you wish to experience that, you will enjoy the movie.
Kent Yee
Kent Yee Vor 4 Monate
It’s like they are trying to sell something on QVC.
Luke Koebele
Luke Koebele Vor 4 Monate
This guy does a good job with his thoughts.
Michael Hollister
Michael Hollister Vor 4 Monate
There might be a "controversy" but just because some don't agree doesn't mean it is "ridiculous." Just sayin'.
Justin Fencsak
Justin Fencsak Vor 4 Monate
Reading the book before seeing the movie right now
Steve V
Steve V Vor 4 Monate
This is how you know if you have any imagination. If you think this movie was too long or boring, you have none. What an awesome flick!!!
trha2222
trha2222 Vor 19 Tage
Best film of 2018. Criminal that it wasn't nominated for Best Picture.
Alan Q. Wake
Alan Q. Wake Vor 3 Monate
Thanks I'll see it asap
grrdpablo1
grrdpablo1 Vor 4 Monate
Of course CBC first to endorse as Oscar gold.
Wayne Michaels
Wayne Michaels Vor 4 Monate
No, it shows Ryan Gosling playing Neil Armstrong playing Ryan Gosling. But these days, that's enough to be "Oscar Worthy", I guess, since that award has nothing to do with how good a movie is.
stiffller russell
stiffller russell Vor 4 Monate
not a chance no were near the right stuff the film was crap very disappointed and stale
Terlon Nannister
Terlon Nannister Vor 4 Monate
That moment when there's this really thoughtful movie about Neil Armstrong and how the moon mission affected him and his family and his grieving over the loss of his daughter, and a bunch of knuckle dragging reactionaries beat their chests and refuse to see it because it doesn't pander enough to their nationalistic sensibilities.
barry nicholas
barry nicholas Vor 3 Monate
Alexander Punturi But the Apollo Missions was nothing more than a pack of lies.
Alexander Punturi
Alexander Punturi Vor 3 Monate
Welcome to 2018; People believe the Earth is flat, the U.S. government loves to harass women, and Americans hate a movie celebrating American achievement. Oh yeah, and the dude kneeling during the pledge of allegiance is more important than all of that combined.
Curious Cat
Curious Cat Vor 3 Monate
I was expecting those knuckle heads to complaint about that one scene in the Houston control room where a black man appears, them going ballistic saying: "WHAT!?!?!? Black people are not smart enough to do rocket stuff!!! Outrageous!!".
Azitock
Azitock Vor 4 Monate
This controversy wouldnt have happened if the makers of the movie didnt publically declare that there wont be a flag planting scene, long before the movie was even released. If they never made that comment, then no one would have noticed, because there were actual american flags in the movie
Tran Hoang Hieu
Tran Hoang Hieu Vor 4 Monate
I watched the movie, and it was patriotic AF. So many flags were shown. This movie is all about the USA. There's a scene it literary spelled out "United State" word by word for you. The only thing it didn't show is the "physical act of planting the flag", it did show the flag prominently on the moon. Whoever believes in this no flag bs, for sure never saw the movie but instead followed garbage news headlight to stir up controversy, like sheep. The PR department for this movie is the worst when they didn't explained it cleary
Kareem LeBaker
Kareem LeBaker Vor 2 Monate
+Vermiliontea oh wow, calm down. This movie is about Neil Armstrong not the Spacerace USA vs USSR
sifu64
sifu64 Vor 3 Monate
Tran- 100% - well said. And this uplifting inspiring masterpiece is the kind of film that's needed in a time saturated with relentless doom/gloom dominated entertainment and CGI comics.
Juan Martinez
Juan Martinez Vor 3 Monate
GlassTopRX7 Two*. One on the moon, one with the kid.
Juan Martinez
Juan Martinez Vor 3 Monate
Vermiliontea And yet they plastered American flags all over it?
J
J Vor 3 Monate
+Nebulous thank you sir and God bless America go Trump 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
damian haber
damian haber Vor 4 Monate
Man has NEVER been to the moon, not even past LEO! Americans told the biggest lie ever!
THE ONE
THE ONE Vor 4 Monate
Ramping up the propaganda and brainwashing because too many people are waking up to the lie. They have to attempt to attach the sheep emotionally to the lie. EARTH IS FLAT
robby dobby
robby dobby Vor 4 Monate
The director did his best not to in any way make this an American patriotic movie.
CHUKY HANDBAG MUSTARD REVIEWS
Even Ryan Gremlins do not look alike Louis Amstrong he convinced me he is a Replicant from the year 2049. He went to the moon with 2 more Blade Runner in order to capture the replicants Off World.
Steve Dow
Steve Dow Vor 4 Monate
I would have paid a lot to see this movie in NYC. The fact that they took out the landmark historical fact of planting the American flag on the moon makes this former 'Liberal' makes me more pro-Trump and MAGA! And why is the American hero portrayed by a Canadian? And his American hero wife portrayed by an Englishwoman? Hollywood is made up of so many fakes, I shall switch to foreign films. At least they are real. I shall wait for 'First Man' to be downloaded by someone for free. Liberal Hollywood: I don't need you.
w oke
w oke Vor 4 Monate
Dont give hollyweird your money, they hate everything great about the USA
Amy Edwards
Amy Edwards Vor 4 Monate
Well actually I'm rooting for Bohemian Rhapsody, the movie about Freddie Mercury which will be released next month. That is Oscar-worthy.
ruslan petrovski
ruslan petrovski Vor 4 Monate
THE BIGGEST FRAUD IN HISTORY................
Omricon
Omricon Vor 4 Monate
I really hope that the crew makes it back to Earth. I'm a bit too scared to see the movie. What if they don't make it back :'(
PETER PEARSON
PETER PEARSON Vor Monat
Don't worry my man. They never went.
Lawrence Allen
Lawrence Allen Vor 4 Monate
This garbage is so anti-American and politically correct I hear the sequel, Apollo 12, is crewed by a black lesbian, a gender-confused hispanic and a transgender Pakistani.
Alexander Punturi
Alexander Punturi Vor 3 Monate
Lawrence Allen if it was politically correct... 🤦‍♂️
Lawrence Allen
Lawrence Allen Vor 4 Monate
We came in peace for all mankind. WE = Americans who paid for it and did it. MANKIND = the ones who didn't. And the thanks we get is a 1969 Revisionist History "#Handsup" moment over our flag? Yeah, I'm rushing right out to see this.
Lawrence Allen
Lawrence Allen Vor 4 Monate
Huh. Hollywood film, eh? So why didn't they have the Canuk kneel when the American flag went up? That would be a much more effective America-hating gesture than omitting the flag planting.
Rozemberg Barbosa
Rozemberg Barbosa Vor 4 Monate
I simply loved this review 😍❤️ the film is apparently well photographed and has serious design atmosphere 💕
Christopher Binder
Christopher Binder Vor 4 Monate
Agreed. All the naysayers are letting their nativist tendencies get the better of them.
Alan Edher
Alan Edher Vor 4 Monate
What was more tragic is that in the movie they don’t show or even mention Armstrong’s time in the Korean War. Nor how as a young teenager he took up odd jobs to pay for his flying lessons. These are experiences that shape a person’s character a great deal.
Danny Hudack
Danny Hudack Vor Monat
His service in the US military would speak highly of a subject the left hates more than anything: the US military. They will never again show the US military in a good light.
Alan Edher
Alan Edher Vor 3 Monate
Director Krennic Sometimes conventional biopics just work better for certain stories, this was one of them. The shaping of a man’s character throughout his life to have the inner strength to take on a mission of this magnitude. If the idea is to make it unconventional then the movie needs to rely heavily on other elements. For example, the Fassbenser movie about Steve Jobs was superb and better than the other “more conventional” one because of its rich dialogue. What other element did this movie rely on? The special effects were just OK so not that. The dialogue was not rich at all. No real emotional attachment was developed for any of the characters to feel sad when they died. This is why they should’ve just focused on his life and the triumph of the human spirit. To each their own though
Director Krennic
Director Krennic Vor 3 Monate
+Alan Edher No, that's what a conventional biopic would do, and they mostly fall flat for that reason. Bizarre you would ask for more 'outstanding highlights of his life' and go on to ostensibly say they should have cut most of his wife/family. That 'petty domestic stuff' is what shaped this story, and rightfully so.
sifu64
sifu64 Vor 3 Monate
a lot more people will be inspired to learn about Neil now. The film covers 1960-9. That's enough of an undertaking. The book is more comprehensive as is almost always the case- hence the art of the screenplay. What you want is more of an HBO mini-series; just as Private Ryan inspired translation of Band of Brothers. First Man is a hands down masterpiece and an important film in a time of hand wringing victimization doom gloom apathy and laziness.
Alexander Punturi
Alexander Punturi Vor 3 Monate
Alan Edher if you know so much about how a movie should or shouldn’t be, why are you complaining on DE-vid and not directing movies? Or have a job critiquing movies?
Dorian Grey
Dorian Grey Vor 4 Monate
Um no its not. This movie is nothing but wild conjecture at its core. No one knows if Neil took anything to the Moon. Know one knows what was going on in his head as he never told anyone. This is all admitted. Why on Earth would I subject myself to wild fantasy in this manner? When it comes to real heroes, only real facts should be put to screen. Tarnishing his legend for what ifs and emotion is a bunch of bs in my opinion. Aside from that, its Ryan Gosling. I would rather bleach my cornea.
G0K3001
G0K3001 Vor 4 Monate
Loved those years of NASA, a incredible AMERICAN feat. I give the movie a C minus.
Vlad G
Vlad G Vor 4 Monate
Oscar bait does not equal "oscar gold"
Flat Earth Victoria Canada
Please Search my video: Karen B. My path to flat earth
Bobby Robby
Bobby Robby Vor 4 Monate
What the hell do Canadians know about American patriotism? This sissy looking Canadian *soy boy* is going to tell us Americans that this movie was patriotic enough. *No it was not.* It could have been. The liberal Canadian director of the liberal "La La Land" did his best to make this was no way near an American patriotic movie. He made sure of it. *He did his best to appeal to the globalist market.* He also did his best to show a depressing non-supporting feminist wife. Yea, Hollywood made sure the wife came off as a feminist. You know, if they had to show supportive house wives then they had to put some feminist crap in it. Everytime she was in the scenes, the movie turned boring and too slow. *The Presentation of our flag on the moon was practically non existent.* One far away wide shot showing, if you can see it, the flag. My brother said coming out of the theater, they didn't show the flag on the moon, I said yes they did but you have to be looking hard to see it. This movie could have made much more money if they put some patriotism in it, because we would have spread the word. But now we tell the truth, good recreations, however the movie for was the globalist market. Many American said, *"No flag - no Ticket"*.
K Mac
K Mac Vor 4 Monate
At first I was upset when I heard about it. Then it turned out to be a whole bunch of NOTHING. Didn't show them 'plant the us flag'? So freaking what? It wasn't like they were hiding it was America that pulled this off. Big todoo over nothing.
PETER PEARSON
PETER PEARSON Vor Monat
Pulled off one of the greatest lies in earth's history... Yes
MrSquifler
MrSquifler Vor 4 Monate
Americans, you'll take any excuse to have a controversy.
Nerdzy
Nerdzy Vor 4 Monate
If people are really going to complain about this they should also want the part where the flag was blown over from the blast of the rocket when they were lifting back off the moon's surface too...
Vincent Arceo
Vincent Arceo Vor 4 Monate
Well only dumbasses would watch Venom over Bad times at the El Royale and First Man... I swear to God if people choose venom over Halloween WTF
Come Visit Waikiki
Come Visit Waikiki Vor 4 Monate
Well I'm sure they did a better job than Stanley did in 1969
The Watchman
The Watchman Vor 4 Monate
Why ignore Hollywood’s endless deep rooted political censorship?
Mike L
Mike L Vor 4 Monate
There are several comments saying the earth is flat. So where is the proof of that? and why are people not falling off the edge? and if they are why is that being reported? and if it is reported why are people not told to keep away from the edge or you might fall off the planet and why are not major motion picture companies making movies about the flat earth and the tremendous loss when people get to close to the edge and when are there not major explorations of the flat earth and how to get to the other side. Do you see how silly this is...that is what happens when you get public education you stop thinking for yourself and common sense goes out the window...or maybe it just falls off the edge of the flat earth.
VoyageOne1
VoyageOne1 Vor 4 Monate
I saw a flat earther playing frisbee once... told him he dropped his basketball 🤣🤣🤣
Craig Sotelo
Craig Sotelo Vor 4 Monate
This movie is not for the weak stomachs I mean the entire movie even when not needed is shaky to the point where it wasn’t enjoyable. I mean when they are just sitting and talking it’s shaky cam wtf I can’t understand why it was filmed this way for scenes it was not needed. There were people walking out the movie I can only imagine it was just so dizzing to watch
First Last
First Last Vor 4 Monate
Ryan committed serious cultural appropriation, and since when was Neal a heartless cold bastard? And why did they intentionally make all of NASA dirty and nasty? Their spacecraft was IMPECCABLY clean. Like a surgery center clean.
Leonard Wong
Leonard Wong Vor 4 Monate
Is it a Netflix production? Probably another Anti USA movie..... nowadays everything out of Hollywood does that.
Jane Kohn
Jane Kohn Vor 4 Monate
Leonard Wong nope
internet !
internet ! Vor 4 Monate
I'm Canadian and I'm ticked off they're not showing the American flag.
Nebulous
Nebulous Vor 4 Monate
Scott Serson - I'm Canadian too and feel the same way. You don't just ignore the most iconic flag planting in history by accident. People keep saying "but but...there's flags in the movie! there's so many flags!"...they just don't get it.
Musicman81Indy
Musicman81Indy Vor 4 Monate
They do show it. They don't show him putting it into the ground but they do show the flag.
Flat Earth Victoria Canada
Hiding comment about the truth?
Tony Mario
Tony Mario Vor 4 Monate
As they saying goes, there are two types of countries in this world. Those who use the metric's system..and those who have been to the moon.
Nächstes Video
The Next Generation Laptop.
11:52