Game Theory: I Solved The Wilbur Soot ARG... And It Only Took 3 Years!

The Game Theorists
Aufrufe 4 140 844
100% 264 000 0

SUBSCRIBE to Catch all the Theories! ► goo.gl/kQWHkJ

If you know Wilbur Soot, then you likely know about his infamously unsolvable ARG. For those NOT in the know, it's time to catch up. Now, this video may seem a little late, but this was indeed a hard one to solve. Yet, I think I did just that. Theorists, we are about to break down this titan of an ARG piece by piece to show you how I SOLVED the Editor Wilbur Soot ARG.

Go through the original ARG! ► de-vid.com/u-playlist?list...
Check out Red Herring's Video ► de-vid.com/u-RedHerringP...

Special thanks to the community around the ARG who have done an incredible job keeping track of Wilbur's crazy antics, especially:
The Editors and Mods: FlaredAverage, Bruce C, MythicalSheep, Christian, Idan, and Inky
As well as: The Wilbur ARG Discord Server, /r/LincolnshirePoacher, /r/SootHouseClues, Alspal, Azure, JackSucksAtLife, Wilbur and Kai.
Join the ARGHaven Discord ► www.reddit.com/r/arghaven/
Find the COMPLETE Google doc here ► docs.google.com/document/d/1Z...

Need Royalty Free Music for your Content? Try Epidemic Sound.
Get A 30 Day Free Trial! ► share.epidemicsound.com/MatPat

FNAF, The FINAL Timeline ►► bit.ly/2MlHYFe
FNAF, The Monster We MISSED! ►► de-vid.com/video/video-_ygN8HLCaJg.html
FNAF This Theory Changes Everything ► bit.ly/2JUQUn6
FNAF, You Were Meant To Lose ► de-vid.com/video/video-7bn8hM9k0b0.html
FNAF 6, No More Secrets ► bit.ly/2LVCq4u

Writers: Matthew Patrick, Zach Stewart, and Tom Robinson
Editors: Dan "Cybert" Seibert, Forrest Lee, Pedro Freitas, and Koen Verhagen
Assistant Editor: Caitie Turner (viridianrosette)
Sound Editor: Yosi Berman




6 Okt 2021



Video herunterladen:

Link wird geladen...


Meine Playlist
Später ansehen
JackSucksAtLife Vor 3 Monate
Oskar Van Peel
Oskar Van Peel Vor 10 Tage
octo Egg
octo Egg Vor Monat
mia natalia
mia natalia Vor Monat
Kenzie Tyaga
Kenzie Tyaga Vor Monat
Abby Da Cookie
Abby Da Cookie Vor Monat
OwO Vor 3 Monate
I actually forgot our big friend that likes to blow up stuff made an arg. Wilbur always surprises me.
nightplayz606 Vor 6 Stunden
Your everywhere
{♡} Blossom • boba {♡}
UwU Vor 3 Tage
Hello brother
Willow Worth
Willow Worth Vor 4 Tage
How are you not verified yet
YTwolfy424 Vor 6 Tage
@Super Sonic um why u so rudeeeeee
StikMan Vor 2 Monate
Game Theory: *Solves possibly one of the hardest ARG’s to exist” Wilbur: Let’s make a brand new one for everyone to solve now :)
💌 ; alligatorwhiskers
whats the new one?
Rebecca Taylor
Rebecca Taylor Vor 14 Tage
@Exi_dudi thanks
Little Blob
Little Blob Vor 15 Tage
Exi_dudi Vor 16 Tage
@Rebecca Taylor alternate reality game
JELLY frog
JELLY frog Vor 21 Tag
@Rebecca Taylor did you even hear the start
Mr Glitch Guy
Mr Glitch Guy Vor 3 Monate
the fact that mat does this every weak on 3 channels is shocking, lets just apreciate the ammount of effort that matpat puts into a video for a moment!
1 Vor 10 Tage
@Mr Glitch Guy Ay ru's reply compliments your comment, if no one had said anything regarding his comment then this thread would've been fine.
No name
No name Vor 29 Tage
@Mr Glitch Guy Welcome to DE-vid comment section
Mr Glitch Guy
Mr Glitch Guy Vor Monat
I was literally only trying to be positive and appreciate the amount of work behind the videos Why did everyone get so aggressive towards each other because I didn't mention the other members of the team, who deserve JUST as much credit as mat pat? Please stop being negative towards everyone because I didn't mention the editors.
curbalist Vor Monat
ppphhhoooeee Vor 2 Monate
900th like
Дети Пламени
As someone who has DID... Thank you matpat for saying how awful this disorder is shown in the media. We are not monsters and we do not kill people or anything like that. It is important to explain people how different we all can be, and how those 'different' people deserve care, respect and support just as much as any other human being. So thank you Matt, it was just a little note to others about a disease, but in reality it was a really important detail that can and will be changing the world for the better in future piece by piece. ❤❤❤
QueasyLemon Vor 3 Tage
Couldn’t have said it better myself -matk
Ikerrad Vor 5 Tage
@Jermaine Beetstra ok, I didn't think it was a joke because it's kinda dark but now I know it's a joke LMFAOO
Jermaine Beetstra
@Ikerrad dude...Think my comment over a little harder. Hint: its a joke.
Ikerrad Vor 5 Tage
@Jermaine Beetstra? I'm talking to the person who made this comment, not the whole DID community (but I hope they cope well with it too)
Jermaine Beetstra
@Ikerrad they're*
Henry Cloutier
Henry Cloutier Vor 2 Monate
I think the girl whom Wilbur falls for’s name is Lenore, because in the Raven by Edgar Allan Poe, the character mentions many times an angel named Lenore, possibly her three favourite Edgar poems were those you mentionned, with her name being Lenore, beggining with L, Elle’s lovely three makes more sense, which would enforce that R. Fakier was the one in love with Lenore, and the one who killed her.
•Noah Cortez•
@Fluffy_Puppy 123 Elle Lenore
Wheelbarrow Vor Monat
my cat is named lenore
Kaede Akamatsu
Kaede Akamatsu Vor 2 Monate
But in the video it is mentioned that only the real wilbur talks about the incident and the happenings
Henry Cloutier
Henry Cloutier Vor 2 Monate
@Fluffy_Puppy 123 could be, anyway ot has something to do with the letter L, fact is she’s probably more related to the poems
Fluffy_Puppy 123
Fluffy_Puppy 123 Vor 2 Monate
@Henry Cloutier Yea true
ChippyGaming Vor 3 Monate
Been a fan of Jack’s channel for a while so I’ve always wanted to see this ARG get solved
FuSiOn EcLiPsE
FuSiOn EcLiPsE Vor 4 Tage
Yoo chippy??? Whatchya doin mate
Jafelle The Gamer
Jafelle The Gamer Vor 3 Monate
Leo Askham
Leo Askham Vor 3 Monate
soobred Vor 3 Monate
i watched you like a year ago
GalaBala Vor 3 Monate
I've never seen one of you comments before
*-__pumpkin guts__-*
Matpat : * finishes Wilbur arg * Wilbur : **starts new one already** Gotta get back to work mat. (also it’s not confirmed but there many things about this in the Halloween live, and Wilbur said when he reacted to this he said “it would be fun to do a arg near Halloween and November.”
Ikerrad Vor 18 Tage
@Chrissy Why do you say that? He might have
Chrissy Vor Monat
He didn't even solve the ARG.....
Obi-Wan Kenobi
Obi-Wan Kenobi Vor 2 Monate
I respect the Ninjago reference at 15:47 so much! The editor of this video is a hero for including that!
stormtrooper360 Vor 2 Monate
I am a sith
Mr. No Audio
Mr. No Audio Vor 2 Monate
Diluc Vor 2 Monate
XwX Num
XwX Num Vor 2 Monate
Mcsipty Vor 2 Monate
TheAdvertisement Vor 2 Monate
I definitely thought there was some interconnected story, with how Wilbur played this consistently crazy character. Didn't realize there was a whole ARG in the works though!
Mossy_teddybear♡ Vor 24 Tage
Lol no one else like
lord of bean
lord of bean Vor 2 Monate
I think I could know what the 1:11 2:33 2:44 clue is. In Wilbur's song "I am very smart," at 1:11, Wilbur says "high school party," and from 2:33 to 2:44 he says "I think I've made a mistake, the first mistake I've ever made." additionally, In the music video, Wilbur wears a bowtie, which could correlate to the saying "it's nice to end things with a bow on top" also mentioned in the arg. Finally, at 2:33, Wilbur changes clothing to the same black shirt he's wearing in the video where he's in the "decrepit old house in the middle of nowhere." This might just be coincidence, but maybe something about a high school party could tie into the arg.
Ikerrad Vor 18 Tage
Sounds cool, I hope matpat sees this
Shaila Gaikwad
Shaila Gaikwad Vor Monat
Dam Vor 3 Monate
Wilbur really makes things so different and interesting, this ARG is clearly like not any other
Crownspear Vor 6 Tage
what's up groomer
Badass Timmy
Badass Timmy Vor Monat
GUYS LOOK DAM COPIES COMMENTS: de-vid.com/video/video-mavosK4ThbY.html
ㅤㅤㅤcan i see
Hi groomer!
Rigby 🍕
Rigby 🍕 Vor Monat
@ocu A rigid gay
Rigby 🍕
Rigby 🍕 Vor Monat
Predator here huh?
Brote McA
Brote McA Vor 2 Monate
Wilbur started a second ARG in Tubbo's Halloween stream, and Tommy was involved this time. I can't wait to see where this goes :D
Taya Barbuto
Taya Barbuto Vor 2 Monate
ais Vor 2 Monate
wilbur said he hasn't done a new arg yet in a recent stream
Ashkin_ Vor 2 Monate
@Tommyranboowilbur Fan4life he was on call with Tommy
DragonsAway Vor 2 Monate
@Tommyranboowilbur Fan4life susbur soot
Tommyranboowilbur Fan4life
But like Wilbur was not there, how did he know he was cold? Wilbur sus
TheAdvertisement Vor 2 Monate
Omg they're starting a new one.
The Nervous System
The Nervous System Vor 2 Monate
Thank you for calling out DID stigma and making it known. From a DID system, mad respect and we appreciate it more than anything. Thank you ❤️
Eclxpse Vor 2 Monate
Hello matpat! Just wanted to point out that DID is only formed by extreme and *repetitive* childhood trauma, not just one traumatic episode in adulthood. No hate to you mate but please do more research on this type of stuff as it can spread misinformation. Thank you!
Impostor Vor 3 Monate
the police should hire matpat as a crime investigator after this
RB plays
RB plays Vor 5 Stunden
Hung Pham
Hung Pham Vor 29 Tage
Crime Theory
Tree Trio
Tree Trio Vor 3 Monate
I would agree of only if Wilbur already said that the ARG had nothing to do with mental illnesses
TobiRevBlackFire Vor 3 Monate
Father Menace
Father Menace Vor 3 Monate
вσкυт – σωl
mat isn't wrong. Wilbur's face is gonna pop up soon again. he and Tommy have already started their new arg
Yeti Spaghetti
Yeti Spaghetti Vor 5 Tage
When MatPat started bringing up the whole “Im so cold” part of this I couldn’t stop hearing “Sleeping In the Cold Below” in my head
Anton Koklin
Anton Koklin Vor 2 Monate
Never seen anyone pointing this out so I guess I'll do it myself. "Wilbur is the creator of E and A guitar strings and of the editing tool of keyframing" where the last would be Adobe After Effects or AE for short. Not sure about how that can help, but I think it's a good finding.
FrydayAtTheCreek Vor 26 Tage
I feel that Mat didn't exactly get it right but I'm sure he's onto something. This was interesting to watch!
Serkoid Vor 3 Monate
Jack finally gets the attention he deserves! Proud of you Jack, been a fan since 2018.
Mr Meme
Mr Meme Vor Monat
2018 The start of the arg
Stxormy! Vor 2 Monate
This reply section is bot heaven-
Little Logic
Little Logic Vor 2 Monate
Same here!
Corners Vor 3 Monate
Saturn Vor 3 Monate
*(BLACKPINK) Lisa :💲"MoNeY"💲 official video - Melody & Rap* de-vid.com/video/video-dNCWe_6HAM8.html
TheRealPringlesMan Vor 2 Monate
As a person who knows a lot about DID, it is not actually possible to develop it at the age Wilbur is in the ARG, the disorder only develops in children, but tends to become more noticeable as time goes on. I don't know if this theory is correct or if Wilbur just didn't know that when he made it but it's something to think about.
Kiddo Vor 2 Monate
The fact that wilbur might’ve started a new arg involving tommy is just making the whole thing better
PotatoGodzilla Vor 2 Monate
I remember when I first learn about Wilbur at Soothouse when it started. Then watched this on 2018. He came a long way and he is very talented.
Fru1ts Vor 3 Monate
Looking at Wilbur’s songs, you can see they represent story’s and have different characters, if you look into it I think it adds in :)
Wilbur: Don’t try to solve the arg, it’s nearly unsolvable. Matpat: That sign can’t stop me because I can’t read!
Willow Heart
Willow Heart Vor 16 Tage
@crep wait you like slugterra too?
crep Vor 16 Tage
*wilbur hold sign that says dont try to solve the arg* *matpat dose it* Wilbur: if those kids could read they would be so offended
Balloutn Vor 19 Tage
@Critter-Creates wait, you read the comment tho
Secret Name
Secret Name Vor 28 Tage
Aphmau verison: Wilbur: Don’t try to solve the arg, it’s nearly unsolvable. Pierce and Ein: That sign can’t stop me because I can’t read!
Willow Heart
Willow Heart Vor Monat
AmericanLight Vor 2 Monate
I swear when Mat Pat recited those poems he let his inner actor our and started to recite for an Audience he knew would come. An audience that would applaud him and love his work.
BelugaDaCat Vor Monat
Wilbur: “Don’t try to solve it, it’s too hard” MatPat: “I’m gonna pretend I didn’t hear that”
Clontbandicoot Vor 3 Monate
the sickest part of this is crywank getting some well deserved recognition, their music has been a big part of my life since early high school so it’s sick seeing so many people talking about them (even if it’s indirectly though the ARG)
mom pls pick me up I'm scared
Quick question: I saw that you used they/them pronouns for Wilbur. For the longest time, I always used he/him. Did Wilbur somehow come out as nb or something? Just genuinely curious and also I will change the pronouns I use for them ofc
Havokx9 Vor 26 Tage
As a Canadian, we’re always really cold without the need for a complicated ARG
 ShortHax Vor 3 Monate
Pfft, you should’ve scared him with some anteaters and it would’ve revealed everything
Saturn Vor 3 Monate
*(BLACKPINK) Lisa :💲"MoNeY"💲 official video - Melody & Rap* de-vid.com/video/video-dNCWe_6HAM8.html
E Vor 3 Monate
876 BABY
876 BABY Vor 3 Monate
DobosXML Vor 3 Monate
Father Menace
Father Menace Vor 3 Monate
Alex Pyle
Alex Pyle Vor 2 Monate
I wish The Game Theorists would do the Oldroot ARG. It's old but it still deserves to be solved
Retaby Vor 2 Monate
wilbur said there's one part where Matpat solved correctly. Only one.
Wilbur: So I made an unsolvable ARG- Matpat: Challenge accepted.
Inoghmia Vor 2 Monate
It's weird hearing a new theory that seems to fit perfectly cause suddenly it seems like the story has ended but until Wilbur doesn't reveal the truth, we can't be sure, that's why I think it's fun and why he'll never confirm anything. This is honestly one of the reasons I love Wilbur sm, he's a great creator in so many different ways
Popplio Trainer
Popplio Trainer Vor 3 Monate
Wilbur makes amazing storylines Also Wilbur-“eats Sand”
Akira Heike
Akira Heike Vor 3 Monate
hmmm sand goes crunch
Dear Theodoza
Dear Theodoza Vor 3 Monate
@⁰•.•InvisibleInnit•.•⁰ and brown m&m-
{Strawberry _Dønutz}
Wilbur:Gets pregnant from a fish and has a fox as a child
Lillian Eve
Lillian Eve Vor 3 Monate
I just learned a new scent.
The beast queen
The beast queen Vor 3 Monate
JuJuBee Vor 2 Monate
Someone should point out that dissociative episodes aren't necessarily confined to DID... They can be a lesser symptom of other personality disorders, people just don't realize how many personality disorders exist.
Prolly Vor 2 Monate
Wilbur, I think, started a new ARG, but this time using Tommy. Two days ago, 24.10.2021, Tubbo did a Halloween stream. Nothing much happened during the stream, just basically bros being bros. In the middle of the stream Tommy called Wilbur and they spoke for a bit, then Wilbur asked Tommy to get him to the microphone, and Wilbur said ''Hello Tubbo's chat, My name is Wilbur Soot.'' and at the end of his sentence he said ''I'm not.'' after he told us to have a great and fine evening. Actually, a long time before Tommy even called Wilbur, he said that he was cold. That could mean something. (It was still in the same stream. He told Raboo that he was cold, but then he also said that he was cold on purpose.) Okay, back to when Tommy called Will. At some point Wilbur asked Tommy who the weakest in the room is. Tommy answered Aimsey. At some point Tommy walked outside, because Wilbur asked him to. He was staring through the window and banging on it as some point. Freddy had locked Tommy out and Tubbo asked him to let Tommy in, but when Freddy went to unlock the door, Tommy started screaming to not unlock the door. Actually, I think that Aimsey went outside to look for Tommy, but she didn't fine him. Some minutes past and he came back all dirty, and with mud on his face and leaves in his hair. When Aimsey tried to help him, he just answered the he's fine and went back to his place. Tommy was sat for almost 10 minutes not saying anything and just staring something. Ranboo tried to help Tommy too, but he didn't let him. After those 10 minutes or so, Tommy left for like another 10 minutes, but when he came back he was in a different outfit, and he was completely different. He seemed much more happier and all. He acted like nothing happened at all. Now that I'm talking about outfits, he changed his shirt like 3 times. I don't know if it means anything, but it could be pointed to Wilbur's alias's during his last ARG. When Wilbur was telling Tommy what to do, he actually listened. Maybe Wilbur is controlling in this ARG? Wilbur said some time ago that he will maybe start a new ARG towards Halloween. Maybe this is it? This is all I saw during the stream. I might have a theory for the ARG.
karishma bhimsingh
karishma bhimsingh Vor 2 Monate
But Wilbur apologised on a stream saying how it was just him being weird and it wasn’t an arg and he’ll actually start an arg soon it was just him being weird or he might just be lying idk the same thing for the roast video too
Prolly Vor 2 Monate
@Gerarrot Probably.
Gerarrot Vor 2 Monate
He’ll probably do it when we have more clues
The Impossible Thespian
Thank you for your comment about DID. One of my best friends deals with this disorder. And it makes me so so sad that media has portrayed it so nastily.
Terra Vor 2 Monate
okay but i find it fascinating how much different sides of the internet are able to overlap. we have now come to the point of matpat knowing the song privately owned spiral galaxy
A Sprinkle Of Anything
Wilbur: *makes a super complicated mystery with a interesting story* Also Wilbur: "I like to eat sand :D"
°•a name•°
°•a name•° Vor 3 Monate
@Totally_Real also more weird stuff and think weird
°•a name•°
°•a name•° Vor 3 Monate
@Totally_Real anyways I'm gonna dance bad so FBI agent will think I'm weird
°•a name•°
°•a name•° Vor 3 Monate
@Totally_Real yes yes
Totally_Real Vor 3 Monate
@°•a name•° this never happened…..
°•a name•°
°•a name•° Vor 3 Monate
@Totally_Real tbh there's oolso another person controlling them
⑈ 『GlitchBur_』 ⑇
I came back to watch this video and I am super hyped for theories on the new ARG, Tommy and Wilbur are both doing together. And really excited on the video based on the new ARG.
hex4_ash Vor 2 Monate
Someone give this man an award He literally solved something like.... THIS good for you matpat
FireGod 22
FireGod 22 Vor 2 Monate
This has to be the best thing you have ever solved absolutely incredible
Dose Of Comedy
Dose Of Comedy Vor 2 Monate
Great video, but might a recomend another ARG that been left unsolved for almost 8 years, The "Oldroot Mystery" is it's name and it's one of the most complex ARGs i've seen. Give it a look!
Cheese Vor 3 Monate
Wilbur: Don’t bother trying to solve it Matpat: How about no ❤️
Maria Stanley
Maria Stanley Vor 3 Monate
@Cheese its fine, idc anymore
Cheese Vor 3 Monate
@Nightmare-Rose you didn’t comment this 👁👄👁
Cheese Vor 3 Monate
@Maria Stanley sorry if it seems like that but I never even saw ur comment
Maria Stanley
Maria Stanley Vor 3 Monate
Mine was a day earlier
Caleb Bartlett
Caleb Bartlett Vor 2 Monate
yo thanks for the disclaimer! Really appreciate it especially since one of my best friends has did. however, i would also like it if u used current vocab associated with the disorder. theyre called alters, not personas or personalities, which implies that theyre just traits of one person instead of different, distinct beings.
Idkanymore Vor 2 Monate
This brought me and my mother an irrational amount of joy because I was laughing my head of and my mum said I sounded just like my older brother who moved out who she misses. So thank you 🤣
hadley hats
hadley hats Vor 2 Monate
18:33 is talking about the letter, Wilbur being socially awkward. In Wilbur’s second letter to Jack after editing Jack’s video that was then published, in the letter Wilbur stated “ I’m no good at social interaction since i was kicked out of the Morcambe Birdwatching Association.” Just a little hint too! ;)
Nat Nat
Nat Nat Vor 2 Monate
This was amazing!! keep up the good work!!
Mace Palpatine
Mace Palpatine Vor 3 Monate
I didn't think I'd see MatPat do a theory on Wilbur but here we are.
Father Menace
Father Menace Vor 3 Monate
To Vanto
To Vanto Vor 3 Monate
David Skep
David Skep Vor 3 Monate
I thought animagician was the only one that was gonna do that
A persun that has a ridiculously long profile name
he can solve anything
Connor Coats
Connor Coats Vor 3 Monate
Almost the 2nd one since he did one on the SMP
Jellygamer Vor 21 Stunde
14:23 the first line in the song states that their mind is filled with hot air as to oppose Wilburs line of I'm cold. Edit: It's not a mistake ✨️ it's a masterpiece✨️
Moss Hive Network
That's some spooky content. I really like ARG explanation videos so this is cool.
gracie. Vor 2 Monate
GAME THEORY!! I have a Theory. Jubilee Line is the last song that could suggest that the cops was after him, and was trying to enter a train. In the song he was explaining a girl, in the part when he was explaining her he said "You shout at the walls.. The walls don't f-ing love you" could mean that he is trying to remember her after accidentally committing manslaughter but he is remembering the bad parts of her and is becoming more angst and angry with her spirit in her mind. Then something must have caught him off guard making him slip and fall and the train crushes him as the ending off the song repeats "There's a reason, That London puts barriers on the tube line, There's a reason, That London puts barriers on the rails" then ends with "There's a reason why they fail". He either saw the cops and committed suicide or either someone/cops/Kai purposely pushed him in. end of theory.
Shady Vor Monat
I have a theory: I think that the music video, Your New Boyfriend has something to do with the ARG. What I think happened was that she left Wilbur for Jared, he got jealous. And that’s when he shoved into the river. Why I personally believe this is because like you had stated, Editor Wilbur has two personalities. And during the video; Wilbur had his glasses off, he was hinged. And in a fit of rage he shoved her into the river
ThatVibeKid Vor 3 Monate
Wilbur: dont waste time solving it MatPat: And I took that personally...
Baniel Vor 3 Monate
@Wilby are you related to this video
Wilby Vor 3 Monate
ThatVibeKid Vor 3 Monate
paola viet
paola viet Vor 3 Monate
ThatVibeKid Vor 3 Monate
@Jessica IKR.
moonn_ [XIAO HAVER!!]
Last year I remember going on a big spree of watching wilbur and Tommy content, and I came across this video, it was a pretty cool video but I hadn’t really payed attention as it was meant to be white noise - so thanks for unburying this little memory mat :D
Ariel Flores
Ariel Flores Vor Monat
“the raven,” “Lenore”, and “Annabelle lee” are poems about death. Really makes you think.
Absolutelykarl Vor 2 Monate
Honestly, this is amazing wow- A GOOD MYSTERY! These videos honestly scare me, i don't know why it's just scary
Jacob Langshaw
Jacob Langshaw Vor 2 Monate
I’ve been thinking about the first ARG and I figured I’d shoot my shot, I believe Kai is “Jared” from all of the songs Wilburs made. I’ve learned about it all today and my conclusion from everything I know about him is he like to add layers to the story, and in the first song he made “I’m very smart” people have been able to link I story line to this character in “I’m in love with an E-Girl” and “Your New Boyfriend” and apparently follow a cohesive story. With that in the first video you’re wearing a bow tie, which “a nice bow on top” was in one of the clue videos for the ARG and makes me come to this story line: Wilbur or I. Fakier was a genius who was born into a rich family, but suffered from lack of interest, because of this he turned to social media where he found an unhealthy parasocial relationship with an E-Girl twitch streamer and she falls in love with Kai or “Jared” and it causes him to have a mental break, and he creates the persona of R. Fakier to cope after he gets asked out on a “date” by the E-Girl and it turns out she’s in love with Kai/Jared but in his anger he pushes her into the river. Kai/Jared, being aware that the girl he is with has gone to tell Wil “ I. Fakier” that she couldn’t be with him is worried when she disappears and knows that Wilber or I. Fakier had to have done something. They meet up at the place she went missing where Kai/Jared was confused about the camera, before Wilbur leaves the hint about being “The New King” and R. Fakier tries to kill Kai/Jared. He survives and poses a threat of exposing I. Fakier for what he’s done. The “Secret” is that he killer her, the “embarrassing” part is the parasocial relationship. My top 3 reasons for this conclusion: 1 : The bow tie and the “topped off with a bow” hint link 2 : Explains why he’s growing a similar attachment to Jack 3 : The fact that so many of the hints involved sounds and music, maybe hinting to his music?
Jackie Mattos
Jackie Mattos Vor 3 Monate
I love how in character it is for Wilbur to describe 2nd degree murder as "embarrassing"
Logan Vor 13 Tage
Yeah lol
Assassin Y🗝️
Jackie Mattos is a nigga
Man who is missing two toenails
Yeah I mean it's way too long to be in prison for someone you dislike enough to kill I'd be embarrassed.
He said it was embarrassing when she was joking
fira mation ???
fira mation ??? Vor 2 Monate
@Advisor Golden Axolotl blood
KillerChara_Mha Vor 2 Monate
Having read the Tell-Tale heart I can confirm that, great draw matt. also AMAZING theory as always.
Nathan Lehn
Nathan Lehn Vor 15 Tage
First game theory where I was following the whole thing. Just watched a random Jack video during the 2018 phase of Jack and suddenly was following an ARG. Then later on Wilbur blew up. Awesome to follow.
How to Suck at Gaming
So waitaminute. This guy creates an ARG to basically confess to 2nd degree murder, and Mat Pat's first reaction is "Hey, make another one!"? I think you will find that accessory before the fact carries a pretty hefty prison sentence, Mat.
Sage Vor 2 Monate
The community thinks the new ARG is starting Matpat! Today on tubbo’s holloween stream there was some weird things happening with Tommy and Wilbur was the cause of them! The community thinks this is the start of the new ARG, and Wilbur was talking about releasing it around this time!
Ella Rose
Ella Rose Vor 2 Monate
yes! i’ve seen lots of theory’s about this!
ghost king666
ghost king666 Vor 3 Monate
Willbur Soot has a real bad habit of leaving his symphonys "forever unfinished"
Imagebear Vor 3 Monate
It's not unfinished . It's unsolved . It's different . One is insult to the creator , one isn't .
cloudy🎗 Vor 3 Monate
wilbur's forever unfinished symphonys :DDDD
Lost Soul
Lost Soul Vor 3 Monate
Zlink Vor 3 Monate
Salviet Vor 2 Monate
Well it's starting to look like there'll be another Wilbur ARG coming up
Topaz Pie
Topaz Pie Vor 2 Monate
I laughed so hard at the “there can only be one” at the start
King UwU
King UwU Vor Monat
I’m currently trying to solve all this, so I’ll definitely take this into note. It actually makes the most sense but, parts of it I’m skeptical of
Mossy_teddybear♡ Vor 24 Tage
I love how he used the cover of “your new boyfriend” seeing as that song is pretty creepy but I love it 🥰
Nevada Vor Monat
Can we just appreciate this dude is literally going insane and paranoid because of SOME EDITING JOB?
Sus Potato
Sus Potato Vor Monat
when I found this video I was so happy for some random reason because I never knew what this ARG was but I'm so happy I get to see my favorite people.
Mentos Vor 16 Tage
“When I discovered that one of the internets biggest gaming creators right now created an ARG, I was intrigued. When I found out it hadn’t been solved, I was aroused”
Sterling Vor 2 Monate
I can’t wait for the next Wilbur ARG since it might have some other people involved as well
Dynamix the Bachelor
Wilbur: "This arg is too hard!" MatPat: "I am... Inevitable."
Hi Inevitable, I'm Sapphire!
Simon Bales
Simon Bales Vor 23 Stunden
curbalist Vor Monat
and he still didn’t solve it 💀
Bigbean Vor 2 Monate
black _ tomon
black _ tomon Vor 2 Monate
Nichirine Vor 3 Tage
Wait, it also kind of explains some memes made of Wilbur eg: the hey girl I’m in water. Does anyone else see a connection with the whole pushing the girl into the water and the memes
Kit-Kat1225 !
Kit-Kat1225 ! Vor 2 Monate
I’ve seen videos on this and this is one of the best. I’ve also heard that wilbur’s new arg started on Tubbo’s Halloween stream
°Eʟɪᴢᴀ° Vor 2 Monate
Something I would like to add is that DID starts from experiencing trauma at a young age. In one of the poems, it says the lines "I was a child and she was a child."
TheAdvertisement Vor 2 Monate
Y'know, it'd be so like Wilbur to discourage Matpar from doing the ARG, just as reverse psychology to actually get him to do it. Crime boy wants to see him suffer. XD
pholtom Vor 3 Monate
Hes beauty, hes grace, he has a profile picture of Matpats face.
Saturn Vor 3 Monate
*(BLACKPINK) Lisa :💲"MoNeY"💲 official video - Melody & Rap* de-vid.com/video/video-dNCWe_6HAM8.html
TobiRevBlackFire Vor 3 Monate
Bee Cryptic
Bee Cryptic Vor 3 Monate
@Just Alexis oh hello burnt potato comrade
Father Menace
Father Menace Vor 3 Monate
Just Alexis
Just Alexis Vor 3 Monate
@Bee Cryptic Ok I confess- I'm actually a burnt potato :( I wouldn't mind if you were an Evil chicken :)
Omega Wolf
Omega Wolf Vor Monat
Dang I love all the Poe references. This was really interesting, honestly, even if it was really difficult. I'm looking forward to the future!
5undy SIMP
5undy SIMP Vor 2 Monate
I just wanna say, Wilbur did start a new ARG (that's what I've heard) and he started with Tommy getting a call from him telling Tommy to do something outside. He told Tommy to do something in mud. When he went outside, he came back covered in mud. So Tommy either got told to play in mud (very weird, but Wilbur would tell Tommy to do that.) or he got told to dig up something in mud, people say he's been told to dig a grave, maybe for the mysterious girl. And Tommy comes back quiet and probably terrified. roughly 10 minutes later, he's back to his talkative self. Transferring maybe personalities like Wilbur. I wanna say Tommy's the new R. Fakier, a replacement of a part of Wilbur that has died. Maybe he needs Tommy to rebuild that part by hiding the evidence somewhere where the police can't find it . But, I wanna hear from you. I also might be digging to deep into this. 😅😅 Watch the stream to get some more info, it was posted my Tubbo VODs. Link is right here! --> de-vid.com/video/video-y7wrtLQa2yM.html
ChaoticCold Vor 16 Tage
I like to imagine that in the ARG there's a random guy who witnesses Wilbur throw Kai and the girl in the river and just doesn't mind it.
Hamborbor 69
Hamborbor 69 Vor 2 Monate
The longer i stare the more creepy Wilbur's smile looks
MonsterIsABlock Vor 3 Monate
MatPat and Wilbur Soot, this is like putting rice and salmon together.
Saturn Vor 3 Monate
*(BLACKPINK) Lisa :💲"MoNeY"💲 official video - Melody & Rap* de-vid.com/video/video-dNCWe_6HAM8.html
TobiRevBlackFire Vor 3 Monate
Father Menace
Father Menace Vor 3 Monate
ItsPW_ Vor 3 Monate
Lol, salmon… I get it.
To Vanto
To Vanto Vor 3 Monate
Hey mat pat!
Rat c:
Rat c: Vor 2 Monate
i already got the start of the next wilburs arg its on Tubbos stream its on the part where everyone is carving pumpkins and tommy and wilbur is on call and they are speaking. IM SO EXCITED hope you will solve it good luck!
wuoi zuiu
wuoi zuiu Vor 2 Monate
Looking at Wilbur’s songs, you can see they represent story’s and have different characters, if you look into it I think it adds in :)
jay Vor 2 Monate
I like this new guy he's funny but realy cool and keeps with the style of the old vids
N o
N o Vor 3 Monate
Wilbur makes great storylines Also Wilbur: A fish impregnated me
TsarErosVonE Vor 3 Monate
@Gustone Anything is better than the movie that literally forced Akira Toryama to make Dragon Ball Super to wash away that movie.
Luke Skywalker
Luke Skywalker Vor 3 Monate
amnesiac Vor 3 Monate
@꧁shadow꧂ its not
Uganda knuckles
Uganda knuckles Vor 3 Monate
Uganda knuckles
Uganda knuckles Vor 3 Monate
@Lilac_ Reed wilbur gay
🌸 Cutie BunBun ☁️
Just a little something i noticed, the window of when wilburs feelings shifted at kai would be between oct 17 and dec 10th, since the email of him wanting the editor job was sent 6 days ago in the video.
Sea-salt Vor 2 Monate
This Wilbur soot arg was hella scary
Johannescooks Vor 12 Tage
You see, ARGs are called ARGs because they will make you go “ARG” with frustration
Winter Dunnahoo
Winter Dunnahoo Vor 3 Monate
This guy amazes me so much. MatPat You Are So Smart! I wouldn't be able to think of why he says I'm so cold. Wilbur needs credit to because he made such an awesome mystery! I'm so exited for the part two!
Just Some Guy without a Mustache
To think that this whole ARG took MatPat 3 years to figure out. At least it's still faster than me trying to solve a Rubik's Cube.
Zer0theUNK Vor Monat
@Justin 張😘🍒 WTF
Rigby 🍕
Rigby 🍕 Vor Monat
EpikGaming Vor Monat
i can solve a rubiks
andro med
andro med Vor 2 Monate
Emma J
Emma J Vor 2 Monate
Eyyyy you got a heart!
☆•different dimensions•☆
congrats mat you did it!...... now do the Halloween stream we need the answers
Sophie Gallagher
Sophie Gallagher Vor 2 Monate
Hey Matpat! I was watching The Halloween stream Tubbo uploaded on TubboVODS from yesterday (24th October 2021) and I noticed something that might be in connection to this theory and could possibly suggest the start of the second Wilbur Soot ARG, so around the times of 1:25:20 until 1:32:49 Tommy is acting very strange. This happens after he receives a call from Wilbur and the first thing he says is "Hello Tubbo's chat, it's me Wilbur Soot" which is almost identical to the introduction to the first ARG during the phone call Wilbur tells Tommy to go outside. After a few minutes Tommy can be seen violently banging on the windows and I saying "no go back don't" and once Tommy does comes back he is covered in mud with ripped and torn clothes and is acting extremely quiet which (as a devoted dream smp fan as I can confirm) is *completely* out of character for Tommy. Another strange "coincidence" is that at 1:34:44 he comes back but *in a blue jacket* and he is suddenly acting normal again without acknowledging anything about the way like the way he acted and the fact he was covered in mud and his clothes were torn. Maybe the different jackets work the same as the glasses did with the different personalities? Perhaps Tommy found out about what Wilbur did to the mystery girl and what he tried to do to Kai (the river) but couldn't tell anyone because one part of him (Blue Jacket) couldn't accept that Wilbur did what he did, due to shock and fear whereas another part of him (the red jacket) tried to confront Wilbur about it and the two reactions conflicted causing the two personalities to form. Also at the beginning of the stream Lovejoy was playing which could be foreshadowing Wilbur's phone call. This may not even be remotely connected and could be a complete convenience but I doubt it, there's just too many "coincidences" for it to just be a funny sketch or something. I hope you see this comment and hope I'm not just the only one who thought this.
Tangle Vor 2 Monate
Yeah! Also to correct you, Tommy was actually screaming "NO, GO BACK, DON'T", saying that he doesn't want them to let him in and then he ran away (Also I don't really think this is a continuation of the old ARG, I think it might be a new one)
Sophie Gallagher
Sophie Gallagher Vor 2 Monate
​@DittoWasntHere That's true! Maybe it is a hint to the start of a new arg? It can't just be a huge coincidence, the convenient phone call, the different jumpers?
DittoWasntHere Vor 2 Monate
Do you not think the first ARG has already ended and this is the start of a potentially new Wilbur ARG which involves more characters than the previous?
Sophie Gallagher
Sophie Gallagher Vor 2 Monate
I thought I was the only one who made the connection. Tommy only starts acting weird *after* Wilbur calls him and tells him to go outside. But what could he have done outside and why was he covered in mud?
Ezra Tack
Ezra Tack Vor 2 Monate
I totally agree, it seems too strange and has too much evidence to just be a bit.
Vic Vian
Vic Vian Vor Monat
I love it how the title says "only took three years" I guess that's life of a theorist doesn't make finding out secrets and story's any less cool Tho
Shawn Vor 2 Monate
Bro.. you utilize your time with great passion. You're lucky.
Film Theory: How To SURVIVE Saw!
Was habe ich gerade geschaut